This in-depth review compares three Audio-Technica open-back headphones: the ATH-R70x, ATH-R70xa, and ATH-R50x. We delve into a detailed analysis of their design, build quality, comfort, included accessories, and most importantly, their sonic performance. Each model offers a unique listening experience, catering to different preferences and priorities. We'll explore the subtle yet significant differences in sound signature, highlighting strengths and weaknesses in various listening scenarios, including music and gaming.This comparison goes beyond subjective impressions, incorporating objective measurements to quantify the variations in frequency response. We examine the comfort and ergonomics of each headphone, considering factors like headband design, earcup material, and adjustability. Ultimately, we aim to help you determine which of these Audio-Technica models best suits your individual needs and budget, whether you prioritize comfort, detailed sound reproduction, or a specific sound signature for your preferred genres of music or gaming experiences.
Pros And Cons
- MSRP of $159.
- Lightweight (just over a couple hundred grams).
- Relatively easy to drive (50 ohms impedance).
- Includes a leatherette pouch and two cables (one with a 2.5mm connector and a quarter-inch adapter).
- Comfortable due to the flexible TPU rubber nuggets and adjustable clamp force.
- Bigger and deeper earpads compared to the original R70X.
- Excellent technical performance and resolution for its price.
- Good bass capability, easily EQ'able.
- Great gaming performance at moderate volumes.
- Slightly brighter and possibly harsh sound at high volumes.
- Telescoping yolk design with pivoting cups allows for height adjustment and better pressure control.
- Wider and taller ear cup opening compared to the original R70X.
- More musical and brighter sound presentation than the original R70X.
- Improved bass delivery.
- Excellent gaming performance, especially at higher volumes, due to less fatiguing sound in the 4-5kHz range.
- Suspension strap's magnet system is weak and may cause the headphones to slip.
- Telescoping yolk shows scratches from the buckle over time.
- Earcups may not fit individuals with very small heads.
Read more: EPZ P50 In-Ear Monitor Review: A Breakout Performer?
Unboxing and Accessories
The ATH-R50x comes with the headphones, a premium leatherette pouch, and two cables: a longer one with a 2.5mm connector and a shorter one for desktop use. The pouch feels surprisingly high-end for its price point. Both cables utilize a secure locking mechanism, ensuring a reliable connection. The longer cable includes a quarter-inch adapter.
The ATH-R70xa's accessory package is simpler, including only the headphones and a single TPU rubber cable with a 2.5mm connector. This cable utilizes the same locking design as the R70x, and the headphones themselves clearly mark the left and right sides. Notably, both cable ends are pinned for left and right channels, eliminating the need to worry about incorrect orientation.
Build Quality and Comfort: R70x vs. R70xa
The ATH-R70xa introduces a significant design change from its predecessor, the R70x. Most notably, it replaces the winglet design with a suspension strap. This change, while potentially more appealing to some, is arguably a step back for others who preferred the original design.
The R70xa boasts a telescoping yolk for height adjustment and pivoting earcups, offering improved adjustability and comfort compared to the fixed cups of the original R70x. However, the magnet system in the suspension strap feels somewhat weak, making it difficult to adjust securely.
Build Quality and Comfort: R50x
The ATH-R50x takes a different approach, eschewing both the winglet and suspension strap designs in favor of a more minimalist style with small, flexible “nuggets” for comfortable pressure distribution. These flexible parts allow for some minor clamp force adjustment.
The R50x earpads are slightly larger and deeper than the R70x, offering increased comfort, while also having a more luxurious velour material. Its adjustable telescoping yolk system, though stiffer than the R70xa's, contributes to a consistent seal.
Sound Quality: Objective Measurements
Objective measurements reveal key differences in the sound profiles of the ATH-R50x and ATH-R70xa. Both exhibit similar bass emphasis, with a roll-off starting around 50-60Hz, but the upper mid-range and low treble tuning is notably different.
The ATH-R50x presents a more “excited” sound, with a stronger emphasis above 1500Hz and less of a recess in the 4-5kHz range. The ATH-R70xa, while having more presence below 1500Hz, has a noticeable dip around 400Hz, impacting vocal and overall sound presentation.
Sound Quality: Subjective Impressions
Subjectively, the ATH-R70xa offers a more refined and musical sound than the original ATH-R70x, with improved note resolution and a slightly brighter presentation. The ATH-R50x, in comparison, has a more forward mid-range, resulting in a brighter, slightly harsher sound at higher volumes.
The ATH-R50x, despite its lower price, demonstrates impressive technical performance, exceeding expectations. Its high resolution and detail retrieval makes it a strong contender for its price range. The ATH-R70xa's more relaxed sound signature makes it ideal for extended listening sessions.
Gaming Performance
For gaming, the ATH-R70xa excels with its relaxed 4-5kHz range, making it less fatiguing at higher volumes while still providing clear sound detail. Its wide soundstage enhances the immersive experience, particularly in games with complex soundscapes.
The ATH-R50x shines in quieter gaming environments, particularly for FPS games, offering exceptional clarity and precision, especially for pinpointing footsteps. It provides a more intimate, focused soundstage. However, at higher volumes, its slight harshness becomes more noticeable.
Conclusion and Recommendations
The Audio-Technica ATH-R70xa offers a refined and more musical listening experience compared to the original R70x, with some ergonomic improvements, albeit minor. The ATH-R50x, while brighter, is a stellar performer at half the price, exhibiting great technical prowess and high resolving power. It is more easily driven, making it highly versatile.
The best choice depends largely on individual preferences. The R70xa's relaxed and wider soundstage, superior base delivery, and enhanced comfort make it worth the higher cost for some. However, the R50x offers exceptional value with its detailed sound and easy-to-drive nature, making it a strong choice for users looking for a balanced option. Both are competitive in the gaming world. The ATH-AR5000 presents a good blend between the two, representing a third option to consider.